Trading Outpost

This Scalping Strategy Punishes Impatient Traders

Every figure, definition and mechanism this video states, chased to the best available source. Where the best available source is trading convention rather than a regulator or an exchange, that is said plainly rather than dressed up.

The charts in this video are illustrative. They are built to show what a failed breakout, a sweep and a reclaim look like, and no chart in it is a record of a real session, a real instrument or a real day. Nothing in the video states a win rate, an average return, a backtest result or a profitability claim, and no source below is offered as evidence for one.

Day trading risk, and what every decision is taxed by

Claim. Day trading is extremely risky, and costs, spread, slippage and leverage tax every decision a trader makes.

FINRA Rule 2270, the Day Trading Risk Disclosure Statement, is the disclosure a member firm must give a non institutional customer before opening a day trading account. It states that “Day trading can be extremely risky”, that day trading “generally is not appropriate for someone of limited resources and limited investment or trading experience and low risk tolerance”, and that a customer “should be prepared to lose all of the funds” used for day trading.

On cost specifically, the same statement says that “Day trading will generate substantial commissions, even if the per trade cost is low”, and that “total daily commissions that you pay on your trades will add to your losses or significantly reduce your earnings”. It also notes that trading with borrowed funds means a trader “can lose more than the funds you originally placed at risk”, which is the leverage point.

Source: FINRA Rule 2270, Day Trading Risk Disclosure Statement. https://www.finra.org/rules-guidance/rulebooks/finra-rules/2270

Spread as a cost, and as a reading of how thin a market is

Claim. Spread is a cost, and a wide spread is a reason to stand aside.

The SEC defines the bid as the highest price a buyer will pay and the ask as the lowest price a seller will accept, and the difference between them as the spread. The size of the spread is one measure of both the liquidity of a market and the size of the transaction cost of trading in it, which is why a widening spread and a thin market are the same observation read two ways.

Sources: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Spread. https://www.sec.gov/answers/spread.htm Investor.gov, Bid Price / Ask Price. https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-basics/glossary/ask-price

Stops, and why a swept level moves price

Claim. Resting stops sitting beyond a level are orders that fire when price reaches them, and their execution adds to the move that triggered them.

The SEC Office of Investor Education and Advocacy states that a stop order is an order to buy or sell once the price reaches a specified stop price, and that when the stop price is reached “a stop order becomes a market order”. It also states that the stop price is not a guaranteed execution price: it is a trigger, and the price actually received “can deviate significantly from the stop price” in a fast moving market where prices change rapidly.

That is the whole of the mechanism this video describes as trapped traders adding fuel. A cluster of stops beyond a level becomes a cluster of market orders the moment price touches it, and market orders take whatever liquidity is resting on the other side. The deviation the SEC warns about is the same event, seen from the account of the trader whose stop was taken.

Source: SEC Investor Bulletin, Understanding Order Types. https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/general-resources/news-alerts/alerts-bulletins/investor-bulletins-14 SEC Investor Bulletin, Stop, Stop Limit, and Trailing Stop Orders. https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/general-resources/news-alerts/alerts-bulletins/investor-bulletins-15

VWAP

Claim. VWAP means volume weighted average price. It is the session average, weighted by volume.

CME Group defines the volume weighted average price as the average price an instrument has traded at through the day, based on both volume and price, and uses a VWAP formula in its own settlement procedures for products where prices come from more than one venue during the settlement window.

The session bounded nature of the figure is visible in how it is defined where it carries a legal meaning. In SEC filings, VWAP is defined for a security as the dollar volume weighted average price on its trading market over a period that begins at the official open of trading and ends at the close, rather than over any longer window. A VWAP carried across a session boundary is a different number and not a fair value reading for the current day, which is why it is calculated from each session’s own open.

Sources: CME Group, Volume Weighted Average Price and Time Weighted Average Price. https://www.cmegroup.com/tools-information/webhelp/acp-ebs-spec-tcp/Content/005.html CME Group, Quick Facts on Settlements. https://www.cmegroup.com/trading/agricultural/files/settlement-price-fact-sheet.pdf CME Group, BrokerTec European Repo VWAP fact sheet. https://www.cmegroup.com/market-data/browse/files/brokertec-european-repo-vwap-fact-sheet.pdf

Volume and emotion arriving together at the open

Claim. At the start of a session, volume arrives in a burst.

Intraday trading volume follows a U shape across the session, heaviest at the open, thinnest through the middle of the day and heavy again into the close. Jain and Joh documented a statistically significant U shaped pattern in New York Stock Exchange stock trading volume across the hours of the day, and the pattern has been re examined repeatedly since, including on NASDAQ stocks in the electronic trading era, where a strong U shape is found in both trading volume and bid ask spread.

The usual explanations are that information based trading concentrates at the open, while rebalancing and benchmark related flow concentrates into the close.

Sources: Jain, P. C. and Joh, G. H., “The Dependence between Hourly Prices and Trading Volume”, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 23 (1988), 269 to 283. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-financial-and-quantitative-analysis/article/abs/dependence-between-hourly-prices-and-trading-volume/C305DB5BFB5F2B2D803BB94449AF8B47 Hua, J., Kong, L. and Wang, Y., “Intraday Dynamics of NASDAQ Stocks in the Electronic Trading Era: Uncovering Strong U Shape Patterns in Trading Volume and Bid Ask Spread”. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/abstract_id=4792199

The opening range, and the five, fifteen and thirty minute windows

Claim. The opening range is the high and the low made during the first chunk of the session, and traders use five, fifteen or thirty minute windows.

This is trading convention rather than a defined term. No exchange rulebook and no regulator defines an opening range, sets its length, or publishes one. What can be established is that the convention is consistent and widely documented: the opening range is described as the high to low envelope of the first minutes of the regular session, commonly the first five to thirty minutes, with the opening range high and the opening range low used as the two reference levels for the rest of the day. Five minute windows are described as producing more signals and more false breaks, and fifteen and thirty minute windows as the more common choices.

That matches what the video says about it, including the part that matters most: the exact number is a choice, and consistency on the market being traded matters more than which of the three is picked.

Sources: multiple independent trading education references describing the same convention. https://crosstrade.io/learn/trading-strategies/opening-range-breakout https://www.tradingview.com/chart/ES1!/3WMRmZts-How-to-Trade-Opening-Range-on-TradingView/ https://ftmo.com/en/blog/opening-range-breakout-strategy-how-to-master-the-1530-us-session/

Not checked

These are stated in the video and are not supported by a primary source, because no primary source for them exists.